Note
Shoshin: Prescription, rather than Remedy
#Prescription, rather than Remedy
I have often wondered how to start this part of the blog: in what am I allowed to not be an expert?
I was recently added to a group chat focussed on a fairly esoteric subject (the confluence of artificial intelligence and nuclear weapons) and it was immediately apparent after sending a short personal history during the icebreaker introductions that I was a housecat among lions; surrounded by people with qualifications far more relevant than any of my own, people who had actually worked in policy setting, people whose erudite works I had actually read in international publications.
I consider myself to have been very fortunate in crossing paths with, and being surrounded by, many leading lights and minor luminaries in various disciplines and coming away with a sense of optimism, interest, and even at times validation, rather than any sense of unbelonging, or otherness. On this occasion, however, I most certainly felt something of an unusual pang of being an impostor.
That is until the metaphorical ice was broken by another relative novice whose own message was greeted by one of the more scholarly members with: "you are allowed to be a relative newcomer". Who was this person who thought that they had the right to decide what someone else is, or is not, allowed to know? What minimum stage in their learning journey on this one topic they were allowed to have reached? Surely only one's self can make that judgement? Life and learning are non-linear. We all may or may not reach any one point in any field at vastly contrasting times to each other. Arguably we should all, no matter our erudition, be approaching subjects with the Zen Buddhist concept of shoshin: the beginner's mind.
Which brings me back to my initial question: in the hyper-connected, lightning-fast, modern world of instant answers and ever-online experts, in what am I, or anyone, allowed to not be an expert?
It seems plain now that the answer should be: everything. No matter how experienced or learned you are (or are not) in any particular subject, you are allowed to be a non-expert. In fact, you should turn up not as someone who feels they already know everything worth knowing, but as someone who remembers there is always some new knowledge to be gained; someone who is ready to learn. You do not need permission to not know something, but a prescription to always consider both your knowledge and your own self a work in progress. Indeed, there is often great enjoyment and power to be found in approaching any subject, including one you already know well, with the fresh eyes and keen mind of an eager student, full of wonder.